Click on one of the people below to find out more information.

  • Kevin M. Reynolds Sr.
    540-672-3700 ext. 112

    Kevin is a co-owner and 3rd generation to work in the dealership.  He graduated from Fork Union Military Adademy, attended the University of Richmond, and served 2 years with the United States Navy.  He has 45 years experience at Reynolds Subaru.  His hobbies are physical fittness, community development and driving his Subaru WRX/STI or Corevette Z06.  Kevin is fortunate to have 2 sons, 2 daughter-in-laws and 4 grandaughters, and 1 Grandson!

  • John S. Reynolds
    Owner/Dealer Operator
    540-672-3700 ext. 134

    My name is John Reynolds, and I am grateful to be co-leading our great team as the fourth generation of Reynolds to be here!  I was born and raised in Orange and currently reside here along with my wife and two children and our dealership mascot, Romeo.  I love motorsports, biking and exploring the great outdoors!  I am pleased to offer our family's care and expertise to assist you in your automotive needs and look forward to meeting you in person!

  • Kevin Reynolds Jr
    Used Car Manager
    540-672-3700 ext 149

    Kevin is our Used Vehicle Operations Director and is a veteran of the auto industry. He has also served professionally as a U.S. Army Field Artillery Officer, Insurance Professional, and senior advisor and administrator at the state and federal government levels.  Kevin is also a professionally rated skydiving instructor and exhibition jumper who applies that same necessary detail oriented focus to your customer satisfaction.

  • David A. Penton
    General Sales Manager
    540-672-3700 ext. 115

    Welcome to Reynolds!  My name is David Penton, I am the general sales manager and have worked with Reynolds GM Subaru for almost 15 years!  Call me anytime at ext 115 with any questions, comments, or observations.  Do NOT ask for Mr Penton, as the receptionist will more than likely transfer you to my father Carl who has been here for 40+ years!  I enjoy working with him daily, as well my team, who I consider the best in business.  We have been ranked number 1 in the country out of every Subaru dealer in the United States for the last 3 years for our sales process.

  • Logan Fincham
    Sales Coordinator
    540-672-3700 ext 122

    I am a home grown product of Orange County, born and raised. In fact, my whole family still lives here in the area. I spend my down time, like most men, wrapped up in football/basketball/whatever other sport is in season. I put in a lot of time in kitchen cooking, which probably stems from my love of good food and my often insatiable appetite! I also enjoy floating the kayaks down the river, and making other new adventures with my wife Jenna and/or my Golden Retriever, Avon Barksdale. Whether coming in for sales or service I look forward to meeting new folks everyday, and I am happy to help however I can!

  • Thomas L. Payette
    Sales and Leasing Professional
    540-672-3700 Ext: 138

    Orange county Native, and Orange high school alumni.  I have been with Reynolds GM-Subaru for 8 years now. I enjoy working with people to find hte right vehicle that fits their needs, and wants.  I try to make your car buying experience a enjoyable one!  On personal side I enjoy working on cars, and spending time with my wife Jenna, and two Sons, and our Dog Lucky, and spending time at the beach.

  • Jermaine Wormley
    Sales and Leasing Professional
    5406723700 ext 144

    Hey my name is Jermaine and I've been in sales for over 18 years! I started out in the Harley Davidson Industry, and I worked in that field for 16 years and now I have joined the Reynolds sales team and look forward to working with you!

  • Tommy Inthisen
    Sales and Leasing Professional

  • Brad Ennis
    Sales and Leasing Consultant

  • Doug Stacy
    Sales and Leasing Professional
    540-672-3700 ext 120

    I'm a native of Charlottesville, The Miller School alumni and have enjoyed working in the automotive industry for over 25 years. My goal with each and every client is simply change their negative perception of buying a new or Pre-owned automobile. Come see how simple it should be.

  • Stacy Plasse
    Client Care Specialist

  • John Pugh
    Product Specialist
    540-672-3700 ext 160

  • Lynn Frye
    Finance Manager
    540-672-3700 ext. 113

    I started here with the Reynolds Family in 1995.  I work with over 50 different credit unions and banks. You can reach me at 540-672-3700, ext 113 or

  • Tracey Cosner
    Finance Manager
    888-442-4861 ext 136

    With 30+ years in the Automotive business, Tracey is a powerhouse of know-how. You may recognize the last name if you are ever in Charlottesville and see the Auto Body shop at Pantops where it all began for her. Joining Reynolds in 2014 as a Finance Manager, her front-of-house presence and good nature gives customers a whole new perspective on financing, and they always leave her office smiling, laughing, and knowing they got the best deal possible.

  • Jay Malone
    Fixed Operations Director

  • Carl Penton
    Warranty Administrator
    5406723700 ext 119

  • Danny Mayes
    Service Manager

  • Caitlyn Cristie
    Service Advisor

  • John Ballin
    Service Advisor